Is It Fair? Make It Fair
When one child cares for an aging parent and the others don't, is an equal inheritance really fair? How lifetime gifting can help make things right.
Have you seen the Saturday Night Live skit that has flooded social media about the elder care plan to take care of an aging parent that is free - free for the brother?
It's good.
This video has created a buzz because it's funny. It's funny because it's true, and people instinctively get it.
In our estate planning practice, we see this too often. Sister takes it upon herself to care for her ailing Mom, often with little help from her siblings. She feels it's her duty, and since she lives in the same town, she answers the call. And to no one's surprise, she is the least financially secure in the family. Her brothers moved out of town long ago to pursue successful careers and have done quite well.
Sure, the brothers check in on Mom now and then, especially to make sure Mom has done her estate planning, but they are happy and content that their sister is doing the work. After all, she wants to do it, she lives in the same town, and what else would she do with her time? They live far away and simply don't have the time.
Fast forward. Mom has died, and sister was named the successor trustee of Mom's living trust estate plan. Mom was always fair to her children, so of course she designed her trust so all three children receive an equal share.
Sister asks the trust attorney if she can be compensated for her time caring for her Mom. The attorney tells her that the trust allows for her compensation as successor trustee following Mom's death, but there is no provision to compensate her for her work before Mom died. Since there was no agreement to pay her for caring for Mom, she generally has no legal claim to compensation for her past efforts. The attorney tells her she can ask her brothers to compensate her out of their share, but she knows they won't.
But what if this was done differently?
What if Mom decided to reward sister for taking care of her, while Mom was still alive? Mom could gift sister a certain amount to thank her for what she has done.
And for most families, there won't be a gift tax. In 2026, the federal estate and gift tax exemption is $15 million. In 2027, it increases to $15.48 million.
FYI. Many people think they can only gift a certain amount each year. This is called the annual gift tax exclusion. Back in the day, it was $10,000. In 2026, it's $19,000. In 2027, it will be $20,000. But that's not the gift limit. Mom can actually give away millions during her lifetime without paying gift tax. The catch is that gifts beyond the annual exclusion reduce her estate tax exemption.
If Mom gifts sister $250,000, she'll use up only a small part of her $15 million exemption. Big deal. She still has almost $15 million left. Bottom line: Mom can make a substantial gift to sister without paying gift tax.
If Mom makes the gift to sister, she doesn't have to agonize over making unequal distributions from her trust. Each child gets an equal share, but sister is rewarded in real time. And this works even better when Mom explains it to all her children, perhaps a family meeting where she explains that sister has graciously agreed to help her, and in appreciation of her kindness and effort, she will make a lifetime gift to sister. Before that meeting, Mom should meet privately with her estate planning attorney to discuss the gift and document her wishes.
It's important to disclose this to the whole family to protect sister. It wouldn’t be a good result if the brothers later claim sister extorted Mom for payment. Everything should be done in sunlight.
This is fair. Expecting sister to do all the work without compensation is not fair.
If you are lucky enough to have a child who is willing to care for you in your sunset years, make it fair. Reward the child who sacrifices her time and resources to help. Because unless you do, you will end up penalizing her and rewarding your other children who didn't help.
There's an old expression: No good deed goes unpunished. Don't make this happen in your family. Reward the good deeds.
Make It Fair for Your Family
If you're ready to plan your estate or update your estate plan, we can help.
Contact us for a free, 15-minute initial call with one of our attorneys.